diff --git a/flow-state/MIGRATION.md b/flow-state/MIGRATION.md index 0317484..550dcd1 100644 --- a/flow-state/MIGRATION.md +++ b/flow-state/MIGRATION.md @@ -206,21 +206,35 @@ looks because the scene it probes is picked from the migrated set and changes between runs — Constellation, then Metaballs, then Floating Geometry — so read it as "comparable to the container" rather than as a precise ratio. -End to end, song variety across twelve songs before and after the epic: +End to end, song variety across twelve songs — and a warning about how to read +it. A single run after the migration gave separation 0.38. Three runs give: ``` - floor observed separation -before 0.1449 0.1508 not computable (the reference sat below the floor) -after 0.1185 0.1376 0.38 +separation 0.314, 0.555, 0.065 mean 0.311, half-range +/-0.245 +floor 0.1073 +/-0.0145 +observed 0.1162 +/-0.0185 +ceiling 0.1434 +/-0.0000 ``` -The floor fell and the gap widened, which is both halves of what the inversion -was supposed to buy. Every structural block moved with it — scale 40→59%, -orient 65→89%, layout 60→111%, texture 89→81%, motion 53→65% of reference. +**Do not quote the separation figure.** It is a ratio of two small differences — +`(observed - floor) / (ceiling - floor)` — and the numerator here is 0.0089 +while each of its terms carries an error bar twice that size. The ratio is not +measuring the generator at this sample size, it is amplifying the noise in both. +The 0.38 that appeared in a single run was meaningless, as was reporting it. -Coupling did not move: -0.09, still indistinguishable from zero. Whether a song -LOOKS different in proportion to how it SOUNDS different remains unsolved, and -nothing in the migration addressed it. +What can be said: the ceiling now sits reliably ABOVE the floor, with zero +variance across runs, where before the epic it landed underneath and the ratio +was not computable at all. That is a change in kind and it is solid. The +magnitude is not. + +The trustworthy measurement in this harness is the DECOMPOSITION, not the +top-line ratio. `decompose` has a noise floor of exactly 0.0000 and effects an +order of magnitude larger than any drift, because it compares renders directly +rather than dividing differences of aggregates. Steer by that. + +Coupling did not move: -0.02 +/-0.03. Whether a song LOOKS different in +proportion to how it SOUNDS different remains unsolved, and nothing in the +migration addressed it. Read that with its caveat: the stage set changed underneath the measurement, so part of the jump is that Metaballs expresses a cast more strongly than